CJN Kekere-Ekun swears in 12 new appeal court justices

Justice Kudirat Kekere-Ekun
The Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN), Justice Kudirat Kekere-Ekun, on Tuesday swore in 12 new Justices of the Court of Appeal, charging them to uphold judicial independence, dispense justice in accordance with the law and their conscience, and protect the integrity of the judiciary.

Kekere-Ekun urged the new Justices to resist undue influence arising from seniority, reputation, personal relationships or the desire to achieve unanimity in their decisions.

She noted that judicial officers increasingly operate in an environment where their decisions are subjected to immediate public scrutiny and commentary, urging them to remain conscious of this reality without allowing it to compromise their adjudicatory responsibilities.

“Public approval must not be the basis for you to depart from the law, just as criticism must not deter you from reaching a decision that your conscience and the law require,” she said.

The CJN further cautioned the Justices against political, financial, social and personal pressures, including those arising from professional familiarity and established relationships.

“Your judicial independence must be guarded against political, financial, social and personal pressures, including those that may arise through professional familiarity or established relationships.

“Conduct yourselves in a manner that leaves no reasonable basis for doubt about your impartiality,” she added.

Kekere-Ekun said the diversity of the appointees’ professional backgrounds would enrich the work of the Court of Appeal, noting that their experiences across different jurisdictions would provide valuable insights into Nigeria’s legal and social realities.

However, she urged them to subject their individual experiences to the common principles of constitutional adjudication, stressing that the law must be applied consistently, fairly and without prejudice.

The CJN also emphasised the importance of continuous judicial education, given the evolving nature of the legal profession and emerging developments in digital commerce, data protection, intellectual property, financial regulation and labour relations.

She particularly highlighted the growing influence of artificial intelligence on the generation and accessibility of legal information, urging the Justices to remain abreast of developments in the field.

Describing their elevation as an important transition in their judicial careers, Kekere-Ekun congratulated the appointees and welcomed them to the Court of Appeal, an institution she said plays a central role in the administration of justice and the development of Nigeria’s jurisprudence.

She noted that the appointments brought together judicial experience from different parts of the country, including the High Courts of Gombe, Bayelsa, Cross River, Benue, Kebbi, Taraba and Ondo States.

Others were elevated from the Federal High Court, the National Industrial Court of Nigeria and the Customary Courts of Appeal of Ekiti and Plateau States.

According to her, the breadth of experience would bring diverse professional perspectives shaped by different jurisdictions, legal traditions and the practical realities of adjudication across the country.

While acknowledging the years of judicial service that earned them their elevation, the CJN reminded the appointees that service at the appellate court comes with a different set of responsibilities and demands a distinct approach to adjudication.

She explained that unlike their previous positions, where most served as sole presiding judges responsible for hearing cases, evaluating evidence and delivering judgments, their new roles would require them to sit in panels, deliberate collectively and reach decisions through judicial engagement.

Kekere-Ekun said the collegiate nature of the Court of Appeal demanded teamwork, intellectual openness and a willingness to consider perspectives different from one’s own.

She therefore urged the new Justices to approach panel deliberations with adequate preparation, mutual respect and open-mindedness.

“Listen attentively, contribute meaningfully and be prepared to reconsider a position where the arguments persuade you to do so,” she advised.

She added that the ability to listen, reflect and learn from colleagues was a mark of judicial maturity, encouraging the new appointees to seek guidance from more experienced Justices on the appellate Bench.

On the demands of appellate adjudication, the CJN charged them to promote consistency in the application of the law, clarify legal principles, correct errors where necessary and contribute to the coherent development of Nigeria’s jurisprudence.

She stressed that an appeal should not be treated as an opportunity to rehear a case merely because another judicial officer might have arrived at a different conclusion.

Rather, she said, appellate Justices must carefully identify the grounds of appeal, examine the record of proceedings, evaluate the findings and reasoning of the lower court, and determine whether the law justifies appellate intervention.

She particularly urged them to exercise caution when reviewing findings of fact and the evaluation of evidence, especially in cases where the appellate court did not have the opportunity to observe the witnesses.

According to her, their responsibility is to correct established errors while respecting findings properly supported by the evidence and applicable law.

The CJN also urged the new Justices to pay equal attention to the quality, clarity and reasoning of their judgments, noting that well-written judgments are essential to the effective administration of justice and the development of sound jurisprudence.